To develop a broad spectrum decontamination system we tested a large number of nanoparticles metal oxides because they are well known for their high catalytic activity. Among these compounds, Magnesium oxide MgO is, according to work carried out separately, able to neutralize chemical toxins and microorganisms.
The aim of this work was to find a single compound acting on both paraoxon (simulating VX) and on bacteria.
Materials and methods
MgO is non-toxic to living organisms and the environment, affordable and active on chemical and biological agents. Producers offering a wide choice of products, 2 of them were tested: MgO-1 (labeled 325mesh) and MgO-2 labeled <nanopowder <50 nm.
The simulant VX: paraoxon
The bacterial strains were Staphylococcus aureus, Escherichia coli and spores of Bacillus subtilis. These strains were chosen because they represent the bacterial diversity. The strains more representative of the threat were tested in a second step and the results will be published later.
Degradation of paraoxon was measured by the means of a spectrophotometer at the wavelength of 270 nm. The antibacterial activity was measured by enumeration of the CFUs in agar medium.
Results and discussion
The two nanopowders of MgO give totally different results.
1- Degradation of paraoxon
Under these experimental conditions, MgO-1 neutralize nearly 90% of paraoxon whereas MgO-2 destroys only 20% after 3 hours of action. With the Fuller’s earth used as a control, 10% of paraoxon was missing, which corresponds to the substrate remaining absorbed on the surface of the powder.
2- Antibacterial action
After 3 hours, MgO-1 destroyed 6 log of E. coli and 3 log of S. aureus while MgO-2 destroyed 2 log of E. coli and did not act on S. aureus.
On the other hand, no compound has an effect on Bacillus spores.
These results are logical because of the bacterial structure: gram-negative bacilli (E. coli) are more sensitive to the direct action of the nanoparticles on the membrane. However, gram-positive bacteria (S. aureus) has an important peptidoglycan which reduces access to the latter. No system using a nano-oxide alone has been described with an effect on Bacillus spores. The tunics and the cortex protect perfectly the spore and the too dry internal medium of the spore does not allow the formation of the oxygenated products.
Gas chromatography (GC-MS) did not reveal degradation by-products because of their too small size. It has even been shown that one of the degradation by-products of paraoxon, that is 4-nitrophenol, is itself degraded by the most active magnesium oxide MgO-1. This is in agreement with the various studies which show that the products resulting from the degradation of chemical toxicants by nano-oxides are not toxic.
Study of the crystal structure
Why do these two MgO nanopowders present such a discrepancy in the results of degradation, whether with respect to chemicals than with microorganisms?
The characteristics of the commercial products are not very explicit: MgO-1: "325mesh" and MgO-2 "nanopowder <50 nm".
We have therefore studied the crystal structure of these two compounds by means of electron microscopy and X-ray diffraction. First, the results show that these compounds exhibit a nanometric size. The MgO-1 particles have an average size of 11 nanometers and are arranged in a sheet (see figure). The MgO-2 particles measure 25 nm on average and are not arranged in a sheet (see figure). It therefore appears that the activity of these nanoparticles is inversely proportional to their size and that the arrangement in a sheet allows a greater surface area of contact between the active particles and the chemical and / or biological substance to be destroyed.
R & D at Ouvry SAS
This work was carried out by the R & D team of Ouvry SAS. This publication follows the poster presented at the "CBRN Research and Innovation, Antibes-Juan-les-Pins, 16-19 March 2015" and has been published in the special issue of Chemico-biological Interactions.
"A new polyvalent product for immediate decontamination"
Amina Sellik, Thierry Pollet, Ludovic Ouvry, Stéphanie Briançon, François Renaud ".
The article is available on the following link
A private copy can be sent to you on request to François Renaud
The first photograph shows MgO-1 at 2 micrometers scale, the second MgO-2 at the same scale and the third MgO-1 at 0.2 micrometers scale. The arrangement in a sheet structure of MgO-1 is clearly seen.
MgO-1 et MgO-2
- MgO-1 à l’échelle 2 micromètres
- MgO-2 à l’échelle 2 micromètres
- MgO-1 à l’échelle 0.2 micromètres